| |
CATHERINE
MAGILL DORMAN: CONFEDERATE HEROINE
OF SABINE PASS BORN
OCT. 7, 1828--DIED DEC. 24, 1897
By
W. T. Block | |
Around
Labor Day of each year, as Sabine
Pass prepares to celebrate its Confederate holiday, Jefferson County citizens
hear much about the 47 Irish defenders of the seaport city. Scrappy Kate Dorman
is by no means as well-known as Lt.
Dick Dowling, but to those Federal troops who had occasion to meet her, she
left an indelible imprint on their memories.
One reason I enjoy keeping
the memory of this dear lady alive is because 95% of the Texas historical markers
of that period commemorate men only. A thousand markers could not reconstruct
the harshness of life in the mid-nineteenth century for countless pioneer Texans.
However, it was doubly harsh for the pioneer women, and one need only to read
the county mortality censuses of that period to see how many young women sacrificed
their lives during childbirth.
Until
recently, a plaque in Sabine
Pass State Park paid some tribute to our Irish heroine, but it was removed
while construction work was in progress there some years ago and was never remounted.
However, a state historical marker has since replaced it. In its issue of December,
1973, Civil War Times Illustrated published a photograph and a brief note about
the diminutive, 4-feet, 10-inch Kate; so did Blue & Gray Magazine in its issue
of September, 1986.1 |
 |
Of
volatile temperament as well as small, Catherine Magill Dorman compensated for
her lack of stature with sheer guts, determination, and an acidic tongue. Little
is known of her life outside of the Civil War years. She was born in Georgia on
October 7, 1828; later she met and married Arthur Magill at Columus, Georgia,
in 1844. For many years, I and other historians believed that Arthur and Kate
Magill were living in Sabine
Pass by 1848 because a 5-year-old daughter that died in 1848 is buried here.
Nevertheless, it now appears that the child's remains were disinterred in Georgia
and were reburied here. However, Bill Quick has now confirmed that couple's presence
in Columbus, Georgia, during the 1850 census, so they must have left Georgia about
1851.2
About
1852, the young couple built the Catfish Hotel, which became Jefferson County's
best-known antebellum inn, about 300 yards north of Fort Griffin. During the battle
of Sept. 8, 1863, a number of Union shells exploded nearby. The 1860 census records
that the two-story hostelry housed 24 permanent guests, including five merchants,
as well as the itinerant seamen who lodged there and enjoyed the inn's excellent
cuisine. It was a seaport landmark second only to the Sabine lighthouse. The hotel
had its own wharf where steamer crews docked while eating there. One historian
once recorded that he had watched Ben Granger, an early day Sabine sawmiller,
stand on the hotel wharf and with a double throw of a cast net, land 176 pan-sized
fish.
That historian, Beaumont attorney T. J. Russell, recorded in his
PIONEER REMINISCENCES OF JEFFERSON COUNTY that in antebellum Sabine
Pass: |
| ".....Arthur McGill
was there and was owner and caterer of the Catfish Hotel situated on the edge
of the Pass, at the north end of the wharves. It was quite a noted place. It was
at that wharf that the writer saw Ben Granger make two throws of his cast net
and catch 176 mullet of good-eating size. McGill died about the beginning of the
war. His widow remained there and afterward married Capt. John Dorman. McGill
left two daughters, the older of whom married Dr. Powhattan Jordan, well-known
in later days in Beaumont. The younger daughter married Major F. C. McReynolds,
who lived at the Pass many years -- is now of Beaumont."3 |
One
incident involving Kate Magill resulted in the first survey of the west Jefferson
County line. One day, an immigrant resident of Sabine, known locally as "Dutch
Margaret," entered the hotel dining room and without known provocation, "proceeded
to villify in blackguard language" the innkeeper while she was serving meals.
Although Kate thoroughly tongue-lashed the intruder to her own satisfaction, three
friends, without the innkeeper's knowledge, carried the quarrel somewhat farther,
met "Dutch Margaret" on the street, and caned her with a parasol.
A lawsuit
resulted, with the plaintiff claiming she had suffered a miscarriage. Later, H.
C. Pedigo, the plaintiff's attorney, questioned the legality of a juror as a bonafide
county resident. Since Will J. Collins lived on what was thought to be the county
line, the commissioners' court agreed to survey it, and in the meantime the suit
was postponed. The suit was subsequently quashed, and three months later, "Dutch
Margaret" gave birth to a son.4
Both
of Kate's husbands were steamboatmen by trade. Arthur Magill was the chief engineer
aboard the T. J. Smith, a Neches River mail packet built in 1857 at Bevilport,
Jasper County, and owned by Capt. Henry Clay Smith of Orange.
In 1858, while riding the 100-foot steamer to Sabine, Henry R. Green, a Beaumont
correspondent of Galveston Weekly News, wrote that the T. J. Smith ran "like lightning
with a thunderbolt after it."5 Green also wrote that "Magill
is scientific in his line, very careful, and experienced." Nevertheless, the engineer
was killed on November 2, 1859, when the vessel's boiler exploded. The T. J. Smith
was later repaired and in 1862 was confiscated by the Confederate States government
when its owner, H. C. Smith, defected to the Federal forces. Probate records reveal
that Kate Magill soon sued Capt. Smith to collect her dead husband's wages. This
was her first encounter in court with the man she would grow to loathe.6
In
1860 the young widow, mother of two young daughters, married a widowed friend
of her deceased husband, Capt. John Dorman, who was master of the Neches River
cotton steamer Doctor Massie.
Tragedy
struck Sabine Pass
in July, 1862, when Jefferson County's worst epidemic, the dreaded "yellow jack"
{yellow fever}, was imported aboard a blockade-runner. In a four-month period,
the disease killed 100 residents at Sabine and Beaumont
and afflicted at least 200 more. The luckier ones, about 90% of Sabine's inhabitants,
fled at the first outbreak, some carrying the disease with them. About forty Confederate
soldiers also died of the disease. Only about 30 men of two military companies
escaped the malady, and their "principal business was to bury the dead."7
When
the hotel tenants and the town's populace fled, Kate turned the Catfish Hotel
into a temporary hospital, for there was then no Confederate medical facility
in the city. Mrs. Dorman and two friends, Sarah Vosburg and Sarah Ann King, were
among the Sabine women who remained to nurse the victims, and all three were fortunate
to escape death. Actually, Vosburg, who was the first person to recognize the
symtoms of the disease, had survived yellow fever at New Orleans, and as a result
was immune to it.8
In
Sept., 1862, while the pestilence still raged, a Union squadron invaded the Pass.
Fort Sabine, with only 16 defenders fit for duty, was evacuated. The invaders
destroyed the fort and its barracks, but generally avoided the town because of
the epidemic. However, they frequently encountered the Confederate cavalry, who
kept the range cattle driven inland to prevent their use by the Bluejackets as
a food supply.9
The Federal Navy armed a captured
steamer, the Dan, harassing all points along Lake Sabine with it, and the little
sidewheeler soon became the special target of the Rebel horsemen, who ultimately
burned the vessel during a fog. On Ocober 15, 1862, fifty of the Dan's crew came
ashore with a boat howitzer and marched twice through Sabine
Pass en route to and from the Confederate cavalry barracks, five miles west
of the town, where they burned fourteen barracks and stables.10
En route, the Federal patrol took Capt. Dorman's horse and cart to mount the howitzer
on, an event recorded in great detail in the Houston Tri-Weekly Telegraph of November
5, as follows:11 |
Mrs. Dorman, who witnessed
the act, became perfectly enraged, and being one of the bravest women in the Confederacy,
gave them just such a tongue-lashing as only a brave woman would dare do. She
shook her fist at them, and told them she hoped our boys would kill the last one
of them before they got back, and if she had 25 men, she could take them and their
cannon with them.
After the enemy retired to their gunboat, they gave
Dorman his horse and cart again, and told him if he did not keep his damned wife's
mouth shut, they would hang him......Mr. and Mrs. Dorman have a large hotel in
the place, and the Yanks declare if she does not apologize to them, they will
burn it. She declares that she will see them in the lower regions first, and they
may burn it if they choose.12 |
Apparently, the Federals
had no real desire to carry out their threat, or to encounter the innkeeper again.
When the Dan sent another patrol ashore seven days later, they burned one-fourth
of the town, including all the sawmill industry and some fine residences, but
they left the Catfish Hotel alone.13
On
September 8, 1863, the war returned to Sabine
Pass in full measure. Unknown to Kate at the time, her old adversary, Capt.
Henry Clay Smith was the Confederate defector to the North who piloted the ill-fated
U. S. gunboat Sachem up the Louisiana channel. The gunboat was one of two which
soon bowed to the gunners of Fort Griffin, and ironically, Capt. Smith was the
only one aboard who escaped.14
Oblivious to the
Federal shells bursting around them, Kate and her friend, Sarah Vosburg, labored
over a hot stove in the Catfish Hotel, cooking meat, doughnuts, and hot coffee.
In the heat of the battle, Kate Dorman went outside, hitched up the same horse
and cart, and carried a hot meal to the grimy gunners in the fort.
One
book, A HISTORY OF JEFFERSON COUNTY, TEXAS, records that: ".....at the height
of the bombardment, two of Sabine's heroines, the innkeeper Kate Dorman and Sarah
Vosburg, arrived at the fort in a buggy and unloaded meat, doughnuts, coffee,
and a gallon of whiskey for the Confederate defenders."15
In his published memoirs of 1899, the former Confederate Lieutenant Joe Chasteen
of Sabine Pass confirmed the story so often told of the Confederate heroines:
|
| …Mrs. Kate Dorman
got in her buggy and Mrs. Sarah Vosburg accompanied her, and they carried food
to the fort. By the time the fight was over, the soldiers met these ladies with
the refreshments…16 |
| In
1902, Andrew Veatch, the editor of a Hemphill newspaper, was visiting in Sabine
Pass when he was asked to write a story about the the Sabine Pass battle. He interviewed
Mrs. Millie Murray, who roomed at the Catfish Hotel throughout the Civil War and
whose future husband, Dr. James Murray, treated the scalded Federal victims of
that battle. Mrs. Murray recalled that she had: |
| .....witnessed the
devotion of the loving Mrs. Dorman in sending the best dinner that was ever prepared
in her hotel down to the fort to cheer the boys as they began answering the challenge
of the foe..."17 |
Kate
and John Dorman resided at Sabine Pass for the remainder of their lives. Capt.
Dorman died there in July, 1886, only three months before a hurricane destroyed
the entire city on October 12, 1886. His indomitable widow survived the hurricane
and on December 24, 1897, she died in her adopted community, where she had withstood
pestilence, war, and storm.18
Three-fourths of
the 47 Davis Guards, including Lt.
Dick Dowling, who defeated the Union Navy during the Battle
of Sabine Pass. died during the yellow fever epidemics at Houston and Galveston
in 1867. In February, 1900, two of the three aged and infirm surviving Irishmen
of the Battle
of Sabine Pass, Michael Carr and P. C. O'Hara, were residents of the Confederate
Soldiers Home in Austin, and they were given train tickets to spend a two-week
vacation re-visiting the remains of old Fort Griffin at Sabine Pass. The soldiers'
first request was --- "Where's Kate? We want to see Kate!" But the diminutive
spitfire who stood ten feet tall in bravery was not there, for Kate had passed
on to her reward two years earlier.
Perhaps
Mrs. Margaret L. Watson paid the most laudatory tribute to the Confederate heroine
in an article she published in the Confederate Veterans Column of the Galveston
DAILY NEWS. Mrs. Watson, who had utilized the column to raise funds for the veterans'
train tickets, probably knew Kate Dorman as well as anyone, for she had lived
in the Catfish Hotel throughout the Civil War years while her husband, Sergeant
Sam Watson, was a cannoneer in Co. B, Spaight's Battalion, aboard the cottonclad
gunboat Uncle Ben during the battle. Mrs. Watson had arranged for Major Felix
McReynolds, the latter's daughter-in-law, Mrs. Arthur McReynolds, and Lt. Joseph
Chasteen to meet O'Hara and Carr and escort them to the battleground. Mrs. Watson
recorded a part of that meeting as follows: |
| ".....These people
mentioned were of peculiar interest and love to these men (Carr and O'Hara), as
the family of Major McReynolds represents the grandchildren of Mrs. Kate Dorman,
whose name will go down in history entwined with the valor of the Davis Guards.
Though she now sleeps in the cemetery at the Pass, she lives forever in the hearts
of these survivors. During the days of the trials and privations of the Civil
War, Mrs. Kate Dorman stood strong and brave under every difficulty. She was the
friend of the private soldiers as well as the officers; she nursed them when sick,
gave the best she had to feed them. She was always on hand in the hour of peril
to express faith in their success, to give an enthusiastic welcome in the hour
of victory...."19 |
One
of Kate Dorman's daughters married Dr. Powhattan Jordan, a former Confederate
surgeon and a pioneer Beaumont physician. Laura Magill, the younger daughter,
married Major Felix McReynolds, one of the county's ablest Confederate defenders,
the executive officer of Griffin's battalion and the commandant of Fort Manhassett
at Sabine Pass.20
On
May 6, 1864, the date that McReynolds led the Sabine garrison of seven infantry
companies to victory at the Battle of Calcasieu Pass, Louisiana, a fellow Beaumonter,
Capt. Joseph Brickhouse, described the major as one "of the bravest officers who
ever drew sword," who rallied "his men in such terms as no one who heard him could
ever forget." Both McReynolds and his wife are buried within a few feet of the
main office of Magnolia Cemetery in Beaumont.21
As of 1972, the thin marble tombstones of Capt. John and Mrs. Kate Dorman
lay cracked and fallen in the Sabine Pass Cemetery. The writer and two of his
then teenage sons hauled sand, gravel and cement from Nederland and remounted
the stones horizontally in a four-foot by eight-foot concrete slab that will withstand
the future hurricanes' ravages of winds and waves.
Until the death of
Mrs. Miriam McReynolds Taylor at Beaumont in 1978, friends could understand the
widow's pride whenever she scanned two dimmed and yellowed photographs of a century
ago. Her brave grandfather, Major McReynolds, and scrappy great grandmother, Kate
Dorman, certainly left their marks on the Civil War history of the seaport community
of Sabine Pass. |
 |
Small
historical marker denotes the Kate Dorman gravesite.
TE photo, March 2007
|
Endnotes
1 J. F. McCormack, "Sabine Pass," CIVIL WAR TIMES ILLUSTRATED (Dec. 1973),
p. 36; E. Jones, "Battle of Sabine Pass," BLUE & GRAY MAGAZINE (Sept., 1986),
p. 15.
2 Dorman and McGill gravestones, as listed in "Sabine Pass Cemetery,"
YELLOWED PAGES (May, 1971), 72-76.
3 U. S. Census, Jefferson County, Texas,
1860, Res. 335; T. J. Russell, "Pioneer Reminiscences of Jefferson County (Beaumont:
1986), p. 37, reprinted from Beaumont JOURNAL, March 4, 1906.
4 IBID., p.
87, reprinted from Beaumont JOURNAL, March 31, 1907.
5 "Letter from Hal,"
Galveston WEEKLY NEWS, Sept. 12, 1858, as reprinted in "Extracts from W. T. Block
(ed.) "The Writings of Henry R. Green," TEXAS GULF HISTORICAL AND BIOGRAPHICAL
RECORD, X (Nov., 1975), p. 67.
6 File 110, Estate of Arthur McGill, Probate
Records, Jefferson County Archives.
7 MSS, "Diary of First Sergeant H. N.
Connor, 1861-1865," Unpublished, p. 2, hereinafter cited as "Connor," copy owned
by W. T. Block; K. D. Keith, "Memoirs of Capt. K. D. Keith," TEXAS GULF HISTORICAL
AND BIOGRAPHICAL RECORD, X (Nov., 1974). 57-58; K. D. Keith, "Military Operations,
Sabine Pass," in BURKE'S TEXAS ALMANAC AND IMMIGRANT'S GUIDE FOR 1883.
8 Dr.
George Holland, "Epidemic at Sabine Pass," Houston TELEGRAPH, Sept. 10, 1862;
Keith, "Memoirs," pp. 57-58; Confederate Veterans Column, Galveston DAILY NEWS,
March 11, 1900.
9 Letters of Col. A. W. Spaight, OFFICIAL RECORDS-ARMIES,
Ser. 1, Vol. XV, 143-147.
10 Connor diary, p. 5-a.
11 "Night Attack at
Sabine Pass," Houston TELEGRAPH, Nov. 5, 1862.
12 IBID., Letter, J. H. to
E. H. Cushing, Nov. 5, 1862.
13 Connor, p. 4.
14 "Memoirs of Lt. Joseph
Chasteen," Confederate Veterans Column, Galveston DAILY NEWS, Sept. 3, 1899.
15 W. T. Block, A HISTORY OF JEFFERSON COUNTY, TEXAS, FROM WILDERNESS TO RECONSTRUCTION
(Nederland: 1976), p. 114.
16 Chasteen Memoirs, Galveston DAILY NEWS, Sept.
3, 1899.
17 Andrew Veatch, "The Story of Fort Dowling," Sabine Pass (Tx.)
NEWS, April 12, 1902. (Note: Locally, Fort Griffin was called 'Fort Dowling' around
1900.) A copy of this newspaper is also owned by the writer.
18 U. S. Manuscript
Censuses, Sabine Pass, Texas, Jefferson County, Texas, 1870, res. 16; 1880, res.
30.
19 Margaret L. Watson, "Battle of Sabine Pass," Confederate Veterans Column,
Galveston DAILY NEWS, March 11, 1900.
20 Beaumont JOURNAL, March 4, 1906.
21 J. A. Brickhouse, "The Battle of Calcasieu Pass, La.," Beaumont ENTERPRISE,
May 9, 1909. | | |
